Invasive Lionfish May Be Superfish Hybrids

The fish taking over the Caribbean is a hybrid of two Indo-Pacific lionfish species.

Published August 16, 2017

It’s been more than 20 years since one of the most destructive invasive species in history was released off the coast of Florida. Originally from the Indian and Pacific Oceans, predatory lionfish have invaded the western Atlantic Ocean, spreading from the American east coast through the Caribbean to southern Brazil, devastating coastal ecosystems with their voracious appetites. Now, new research has revealed that invasive lionfish are not quite what they seem.

“Marine invasions … are a scourge,” says Brian Bowen, a geneticist at the University of Hawai‘i. “But this is an invasion of what could be a superfish.”

Twelve species of lionfish live in the Indo-Pacific, but only two closely related ones were thought to comprise the lionfish invasion: red lionfish, Pterois volitans, and common lionfish, Pterois miles. Most of the western Atlantic invaders were identified as red lionfish, though the two lionfish are almost indistinguishable in appearance. For the past decade, marine biologists studying the lionfish invasion have assumed that most of the invaders are red lionfish. But a new study, recently published in the Journal of Heredity, flips the whole situation on its head.

As a team of researchers from the University of Hawai‘i and Japan’s Kochi University and the Kagoshima University Museum have discovered, the red lionfish isn’t even a species at all. Instead, it is a hybrid of two other lionfish species—P. miles from the Indian Ocean; and the Russell’s lionfish, Pterois russelii, from the Pacific. So in some sense, the lionfish taking over the western Atlantic are not an invasive species—they’re an invasive hybrid. It’s a situation never before seen in a marine biological invasion. This revelation may help explain the lionfish’s staggering success as an invader by hinting at secrets hidden in its genes.

The scientists made their discovery following an analysis of the invasive lionfish’s nuclear DNA. Past genetic studies on the fish have focused on their mitochondrial DNA. While much easier for scientists to collect, mitochondrial DNA—which is found in an animal’s mitochondria, and is passed down from mother to offspring—represents only a fraction of an organism’s genetic family tree. Nuclear DNA, found in the nucleus, gives a more complete representation of a fish’s genetic diversity. Recent advances in sequencing technology allowed the researchers to analyze the nuclear DNA of 286 lionfish that were collected from three oceans over the past decade.

The scientists found that of the invasive lionfish in the Atlantic Ocean, 89 percent were the Indo-Pacific hybrids. Even in the Pacific and Indian Oceans, these hybrids occupy an expansive range, stretching from the eastern Indian Ocean to Japan to the South Pacific.

“We’ve never seen anything like this, where the hybrid has a vast range,” says Bowen. “Usually we find there’s an Indian Ocean species and a Pacific species, and they hybridize on a few islands at the boundary.”

Based on their prolific success in both native and invaded waters, the scientists suggest these hybrid lionfish may be benefiting from a process called heterosis, which occurs when the offspring of genetically dissimilar parents—such as a mutt born from two different kinds of purebred dog—is healthier and more fit than its parents. Crossbreeding doesn’t always cause heterosis, but it can weed out harmful genes from inbreeding, or amplify beneficial genes.

Though the researchers didn’t specifically test for heterosis, several lines of evidence indicate it may be fueling the lionfish invasion, says Bowen. The hybrids’ huge range suggests they might be stronger and more reproductively successful than their parent species. Invasive lionfish also grow faster and larger.

“When you introduce something, it has a couple of advantages. It loses its parasite load, its predators, and its prey is naive,” says Bowen. “But is it the advantage of being introduced to a naive environment, or is it the heterosis? We haven’t answered that yet.”

“I bet it’s both,” he adds.

Isabelle Côté, a marine ecologist at Simon Fraser University in Burnaby, British Columbia, says the new research is “an amazing new piece of the puzzle.” She says the new findings may call into question past research comparing lionfish in the Atlantic to those in the Indo-Pacific.

“Unless the comparisons are made specifically at the point where the hybrid is … we may actually be comparing different species,” Côté says. “Now it might well be that some of these comparisons are—I wouldn’t say flawed—but not quite right.”

While the scientists’ findings do not offer new ways to fight the lionfish invasion, Bowen says the discovery underscores the urgency of addressing it, and the need for further research that could lead to a solution.    

Correction: The original headline of this article was “Invasive Lionfish Are Superfish Hybrids.” Though the fish are indeed hybrids, their “superfish” status remains up for debate.